How we rate ingredients
Each ingredient gets one of three ratings. Here is exactly how we decide.
Low concern Low concern. Usually an ingredient the U.S. EPA's Safer Choice program lists as a Green circle (verified low concern) or Green half-circle (expected low concern), with no major documented caveat at dish soap use levels.
Use with care Use with care. One specific caveat is well documented: for example, EPA's Yellow triangle code (best-in-class for its function, but not low concern on every hazard endpoint), skin sensitization, a possible trace contaminant like 1,4-dioxane, poor biodegradability, an undisclosed mixture like "fragrance", or an open scientific debate.
Higher concern Higher concern. A significant, well-documented issue: for example, a regulatory restriction or listing (FDA's 2016 removal of triclosan from consumer antiseptic washes, California Prop 65), a formaldehyde-releasing preservative, a strong skin allergen, or a major environmental impact like phosphate-driven algae blooms. Safer alternatives exist.
EPA Safer Choice codes, explained
- Green circle: "verified to be of low concern based on experimental and modeled data."
- Green half-circle: "expected to be of low concern," though "additional data would strengthen our confidence."
- Yellow triangle: met Safer Choice criteria for its functional class "but has some hazard profile issues"; best-in-class, but "an area for safer chemistry innovation."
Quotes are from the EPA Safer Chemical Ingredients List. Not being on the list doesn't automatically mean an ingredient is unsafe; the list isn't exhaustive.
Dose and exposure matter
Dish soap is diluted and rinsed off. Many cautions (for example, about concentrated alkalis or enzyme dust) apply mainly to the undiluted product or to factory workers. We say so in each card.
Same rules for everyone
We apply these rules to Green Llama's ingredients too. That's why their enzymes and TAED show as yellow: EPA codes them Yellow triangle.
Matching your label
The decoder matches ingredient names, common synonyms, INCI names, and some CAS-style chemical names, and it tolerates small typos. If we don't recognize an ingredient, we tell you instead of guessing, and we point you to PubChem and EPA lookups.
Corrections
Science evolves. Each ingredient page lists its sources and a last-reviewed date. If you spot an error, contact Green Llama through their contact page and mention whatsinmydishsoap.com.